Check that you have done all these things:
- Go into bar (west side).
- Talk to Wild Rick.
- Get spoiled wine from basement. Give it to Rick.
- Take Rick's money bag. Leave bar.
- Outside the bar, talk to Jack... who is happy to get the money.
- Go east to Jack's ship.
- Put 4 large cannonballs on 4 targets on ship.
- Talk to red-bearded pirate on beach.
- Drag rum barrel from ship to target.
- Target appears in front of cannon. Put cannonball on it.
- Shoot cannon / destroy statue.
- Pirate who was blocking lower deck comes up... now out of the way.
- Go to lower deck. Talk to the friar.
- Chase the monkey to the room at the top that has two hammocks.
- Go back to the friar, who then moves.
- Enter the room. Get metal key.
- Go back to house with pirate flags. Get the two keys in the upper left corner.
- Go to small house in the south. Look through telescope. Remember placement of the red X that you see.
- Go to small house in the north. Look through telescope. Remember placement of 2 red X's.
- Go out. Put 3 stones where you saw red X's in the telescopes.
- If stones are correct, the gold key will appear.
- Take gold key to big house with pirate flags.
- Get doll out of Jack's room.
You might need to go back into the small houses and look through the telescopes again to make sure your stones are on the red X's.