Take heed in the advice @gamemaster is giving you. He's done this event like 5x and his computer/mouse just play on their own☺
In general, when a Quest requires a player to make a recipe, it is ALWAYS for the first recipe in the Event. A player NEVER has to use their Achievement items for it. In fact, its a good idea to not even activate the 2nd recipe to ensure you don't use the collected items til after buying the desired equipment.
🐦 I should add that sometimes the ACHIEVEMENT is actually a recipe item. So the ingredients collected in either the repeatable mines or regular Event locations are used to create the recipe. One example is Little Red Riding Hood (Shop) where the Achievement was making Red Velvet Cupcakes; thus strawberries collected were used in that recipe.